A Question of Trust (10 English)
This story explores themes of deception and trust through the interaction between a housewife and a burglar. It examines how assumptions about character ca
TL;DR: This story explores themes of deception and trust through the interaction between a housewife and a burglar. It examines how assumptions about charact…
Written & reviewed by the Syllab.in Academic Team (CBSE/NCERT subject experts) · Updated
This story explores themes of deception and trust through the interaction between a housewife and a burglar. It examines how assumptions about character ca
A Question of Trust — Summary
A burglar breaks into a house and encounters the housewife, Mrs. Crumb, who is calm rather than panicked. The burglar, holding a gun, is surprised by her composure. Mrs. Crumb offers him tea and treats him kindly, engaging him in conversation. She makes an appeal to his humanity, suggesting that he is not truly a bad person. The burglar becomes confused and eventually tells her about his impoverished background and desperation that drove him to crime. Mrs. Crumb sympathizes with him and persuades him to trust her with his gun while he eats. Once the burglar surrenders the weapon, Mrs. Crumb reveals that she has already called the police and the burgling was a test set up by her husband to prove her point about trust. The story explores the complex dynamics between aggressor and victim, the power of kindness, and how trust can be manipulated.
Characters
- Mrs. Crumb: A clever woman who uses kindness and psychology to disarm a burglar and prove a point about trust and human nature.
- The Burglar: A desperate man driven to crime by poverty who is swayed by kindness and shown to be redeemable.
Themes
- Trust and deception
- Human nature and redemption
- Power dynamics
- Kindness as a weapon
- Appearance versus reality
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Mrs. Crumb show kindness to the burglar?
Mrs. Crumb shows kindness because she believes in the inherent goodness of people. She uses empathy and compassion strategically to appeal to the burglar's better nature and disarm him psychologically.
What is the twist at the end?
The twist reveals that Mrs. Crumb had already called the police and that the entire burglary was orchestrated by her husband. She used the situation to prove her philosophy about trust and human goodness.
More 10 English Chapters
- A Letter to God
- Nelson Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom
- Two Stories about Flying
- From the Diary of Anne Frank
- The Hundred Dresses
- Glimpses of India
🤖 Stuck on any of these? Ask Syllab's free AI Tutor to explain step by step →